The objections have been so intense and the effort so concerted that it does not feel out of place to ask if there is a deeper intent, a deliberate effort behind all the critiques, objections, characterisations and dirty tricks that the movement is attracting. Nothing is easier in argument than to either characterise the other side with adjectives of your choosing and to inflate a germ of doubt that you can plausibly detect into a full blown epidemic of distrust or try and denigrate the credentials of those one is opposed to and to focus on who they are rather than on the idea that they represent.

Part of an excellent blog post on criticism by Santosh Desai.

This part in particular struck a chord with us, as it dives into the world of intense objections and hidden motives. This reflection prompts us to ponder the role of criticism and the strategies often used in such discussions.

It highlights a common tactic in arguments – the use of strong labels to paint the opposing side in a certain light. It’s a reminder that it’s easy to throw around labels that fit our narrative, which can lead to an atmosphere of doubt. The notion of blowing a small doubt out of proportion is something we’ve all seen, and it underscores the importance of approaching criticism with a discerning eye, focusing on the underlying intent rather than the emotional language.

The idea of discrediting the credentials of those we disagree with is another aspect Desai points out. This approach shifts attention away from the actual idea and onto the people presenting it. It’s a tactic that can sidetrack discussions and cloud the real issue. Desai’s perspective encourages us to stay on track and focus on the essence of the argument, regardless of who’s voicing it.

In the context of creative work, these insights are incredibly relevant. They remind us to approach criticism constructively, evaluating ideas based on their worth rather than getting caught up in the tactics used to present them. Recognizing the strategies that can muddle discussions empowers us to engage in meaningful conversations that lead to growth and innovation.